DatacenterDisk

Seagate BarraCuda vs WD Ultrastar

Side-by-side spec and price comparison. Live data from Amazon US.

+ Add driveShare comparison
Our Recommendation
👑
WD Ultrastar DC HC580 24TB Renewed

WD Ultrastar DC HC580 24TB Renewed wins on both price ($27.88/TB) and warranty (5 years).

Best $/TB: WD
Best Warranty: WD
Best for RAID: WD
Full Specification Comparison
Spec
Seagate
BarraCuda 24TB ST24000DM001
$31.21/TB
WD
Ultrastar DC HC580 24TB Renewed
$27.88/TB
Brand
Seagate
WD
Model
BarraCuda 24TB ST24000DM001
Ultrastar DC HC580 24TB Renewed
Series
BarraCuda
Ultrastar DC
Part Number
ST24000DM001
WUH722424BLE6L4
$/TB
$31.21
👑$27.88
Price
$749.00
$669.00
Condition
New
New
Capacity
24TB
24TB
Interface
SATA-6G
SATA-6G
Form Factor
3.5"
3.5"
Drive Type
HDD
HDD
Recording Tech
CMR
ePMR
RPM
7,200
7,200
Cache
512MB
512MB
Sector Size
—
512e
Workload Rating
—
550TB/yr
DWPD
N/A
N/A
Warranty
—
5 years
Workload Tier
desktop
nearline
In Stock
✓ In Stock
✓ In Stock
Buy
Buy on Amazon →
Buy on Amazon →
Workload Fit
Workload
Seagate
WD
NAS Storage
●●●
●●●
Backup Target
●●●
●●●
OLTP Database
●
●
Cold Archive
●●●
●●●
Virtualization
●
●
AI/ML Storage
●●
●●
Buying Recommendation
Choose Seagate BarraCuda 24TB ST24000DM001 if:
  • ✓ You need new-with-warranty for compliance or budgeting
  • ✓ You need high-density storage for bulk/archive workloads
Buy Seagate →
Choose WD Ultrastar DC HC580 24TB Renewed if:
  • ✓ You need maximum storage per dollar
  • ✓ You need 5-year warranty coverage for production
  • ✓ You're building a RAID array and need guaranteed CMR compatibility
  • ✓ Your server runs 24/7 under heavy sustained load
Buy WD →

Frequently Asked Questions

WD Ultrastar offers better value at $27.88/TB vs $31.21/TB - a 11% price difference. Factor in warranty length and workload rating when the price gap is small.

Mixing drives of different models in RAID is not recommended even if capacities match. Different firmware, error handling and seek patterns can cause rebuild issues. Use identical drives within the same RAID group for reliable operation.

WD Ultrastar carries a longer 5-year warranty vs unknown years for Seagate BarraCuda. Both are enterprise-grade drives built for 24/7 operation.

Seagate BarraCuda is the better fit for NAS storage. It uses CMR recording which is safe for all RAID levels. SATA interface is compatible with all NAS platforms including Synology, QNAP and TrueNAS.

Seagate BarraCuda vs WD Ultrastar - Comparison | DatacenterDisk